Monday, July 8, 2013

What Is a Mock P&T Committee and What Is the Best Way to Conduct Them?

Stanton R. Mehr, President, SM Health Communications LLC

In the course of a pharmaceutical launch program, most savvy product managers and brand directors will want to test, compare, and evaluate their managed markets launch strategy in a way that gives them a realistic understanding of how their strategy will fare in the real rough-and-tumble world of health plans, insurers, and pharmacy benefit managers. For most products provided in ambulatory settings in the US, these payer institutions control the majority of coverage decision-making and reimbursement. Therefore, at some time prior to product launch, a litmus test of marketing plans is necessary.
            That final overarching answer—will my product be placed on formulary and on what copayment/coinsurance tier?—is the $1 billion question for most pharma companies. This is everyone’s goal, but few well-proven options exist to obtain strong, reliable response to the question. Even the term that pharma executives use to describe how they will obtain the answer is vague in the minds of most. “We will hold a ‘mock Pharmacy & Therapeutics Committee”: What exactly does that mean? Is it a separate tactic or something that is part of another more common managed markets tool?
            Primarily, a P&T Committee is the coverage decision-making body within a health plan, insurer, hospital, or PBM that evaluates whether a product is safe, effective, and of sufficient value to be considered for reimbursement by the plan for its members. In many ways, it is a technology assessment committee, comparing new pharma products and/or delivery devices against what the organization already covers to decide whether the new technology is of sufficient value to its members. In an actual health plan or PBM setting, the P&T Committee meets on a regular basis (e.g., monthly or quarterly) and spends time deemed sufficient to explore the product in question and vote its assent or dissent on coverage. Therefore, if the objective to holding a mock P&T Committee is to obtain a response as close to that seen in a real Committee setting, it is best to emulate the latter as closely as possible.

What a Mock P&T Is, and What It Isn’t. This means that one broad requisite for holding an effective mock P&T Committee is that it is a live meeting of managed markets experts. However, this can be done in a multitude of ways, and each of which carry their own rewards (but risks, too).  

(1)  Managed care advisory boards or webinars—well known, once ubiquitous, managed care advisory boards typically brought up to 15 managed care medical directors and pharmacy directors into one room, with pharmaceutical sponsors sitting either at the roundtable or in the back of the room. Sometimes run directly by the pharmaceutical marketing team or a professional facilitator, the goal of the ad board (which were often done as a series held in geographical regions or by types of plans or insurers) was to obtain responses to a specific list of questions posed by the marketing team. In some cases, a “mock P&T Committee” scenario is included in some portion of the ad board agenda, to try to tease out the whether the managed care executives will, in the end, place the product in question on a health plan formulary. The goal of an advisory board is not necessarily the same as that for the mock P&T Committee. In this setting, part of the problem resides in the very room where the mock P&T is held. In no managed care organization are pharmaceutical company representatives allowed to participate in P&T Committee meetings. This would bias the proceedings and would like inhibit directed, full discussion of the company’s product (or competition).
(2)  P&T “wargames”—P&T wargames are marketing activities in which pharmaceutical company personnel combine with managed care consultants to play the role of health plan executives, not to obtain accurate formulary decisions, but to devise marketing strategies and approaches in response to possible outcomes of the formulary decision. In other words, if one of the possible outcomes of a P&T Committee decision is that Product X will not be placed on formulary because it doesn’t provide sufficient value over presently covered agents, then the wargames team may suggest increasing contracted rebates or discounts to overcome this barrier. However, the P&T wargames is not focused on what outcome is most likely, only what to do in the event it occurs.
(3)  Product theatres—Product theatres, often run at major clinical and professional conventions, offers the chance for pharmaceutical companies to present their marketing story to large groups of managed care professionals. This can be accompanied by a staged P&T Committee review, where some of the issues that may be raised in a real P&T Committee may acted out for the benefit of the larger audience, along with some possible responses.
(4)  The virtual P&T Committee—In this format, a P&T Committee meets on a regular basis, just like a real P&T Committee, to evaluate specific products or drug classes for virtual health plan or PBM. That is, it may represent a specific type of plan, such as a 1-million member regional point-of-service plan, based on the East Coast, or a 500,000-member integrated health plan based in California. The committee members are usually blinded to which pharmaceutical company is sponsoring a session (as part of their regular meeting), and pharma executives are prohibited from attending the meeting in real-time (that is, no one but the Committee members are allowed in the conference room, no use of one-way mirrored observation rooms, and no satellite feed of the actual meeting to other sites). This minimizes inherent biases in discussions and decision making. It also assures that all discussions and comments are encouraged, with regard to how a real P&T Committee approaches the disease state, drug class, or specific product. The result of the virtual P&T Committee is a formulary decision based on a clearly developed scenario, which will set a standard for how real managed care organizations of similar type will most likely vote on the product. It is an outcomes report based on one scenario (which can be a certain pricing level, including specific assumptions on formulary positioning of competitive products, and of course, the value proposition).

It is therefore as important to remember what a mock P&T Committee is versus what it is not. What type of live meeting of managed care experts a pharma company chooses to achieve its goals really depends on what the expectations or objectives of that exercise. If seeking possible responses to a set of P&T Committee decisions, a “wargames” scenario may be most appropriate. If looking for general feedback on the managed care marketing strategy or trying to develop the initial strategy is main objective, an ad board or series of boards may be the ticket. But if the product team is seeking to understand what is the likeliest P&T Committee decision based on their product launch, the virtual P&T meeting is the best way to go.

Not Just for a New Product Launch. Although the most obvious use of a virtual P&T Committee meeting is for a pharmaceutical company seeking to test the outcome for their own new soon-to-be-launched agent, it can be at least as useful to better understand the effect of a competitor’s new entry on the company’s mature product. Virtual P&T Committees have enabled a marketing team to “pre-position” the competitor’s product, based on reaction from the committee members, as well as conduct essential business intelligence on the probability that the new agent will be (1) accepted onto the formulary, (2) at what copayment tier, and (3) what effect, if any, if will have on the rest of the product class. For example, will Product Y’s acceptance onto the formulary at the preferred tier require all other products of the class to require prior authorization before coverage can be obtained? The drug company can then determine if a new strategy is necessary, such as increased rebating or better comparative-effectiveness research will help mitigate these effects.

Again, what is the real objective of conducting a mock P&T? That should define which format provides the greatest chance of success in answering the question.

SM Health Communications provides writing, consulting, and market research services for the long-term care and payer markets. Its proprietary P&T Insight™ virtual P&T Committee program is the leading mock P&T Committee product in the field. For more information, please visit or contact Stanton R. Mehr, President, at


  1. Great information - thanks a lot for the detailed article! You might also be interested to know more about our company. Techno Data Group helps you achieve your business goals through customized database, connect with interested qualified prospects who are seeking information to move forward in the buying process.Pharmacy Director Email List

  2. I wanted to say that I have loved this blog.Very informative post with lots of information included in the posting.
    You have made some really good points here ! You might also be interested to know more about generating more leads and getting the right intelligence to engage prospects.E-Health Care Lists implements new lead gen ideas and strategies for generating more leads and targeting the right leads and accounts.E-Health Care Lists is one of the global suppliers of healthcare mailing list & email list.Marketing to the healthcare industry, reaching the doctors and other healthcare decision makers is often an impossibletask.Please refer to
    Chairman of P&T Committee Mailing list & Email list